Is New York below sea level?
New York, the largest city of the United States, lies where the Hudson River meets the Atlantic. The map covers 80 by 60 km: the five boroughs, part of New Jersey and western Long Island, on the USGS elevation model (3D Elevation Program).
Only 20.9 km² (8 square miles) below zero
In the map area only 20.9 km² (8 square miles) of land lies below today's mean sea level, less than 1% of the land on the map, in small scattered spots. New York does not lie in a depression like Amsterdam: the typical height of the area around Lower Manhattan is about +3.3 m, and of Midtown about +16.4 m. The lowest ground is along the bays, the marshes and the beaches, such as Coney Island, where the typical height is about +1.8 m.
American heights are given relative to NAVD88. We convert them to mean sea level as measured by NOAA at The Battery station at the southern tip of Manhattan (1983 to 2001): there, 0 m NAVD88 lies 6 cm above mean sea level.
At +1 m and +2 m: bay shores, marshes and beaches
At +1 m the water covers 59.7 km² (23 square miles) of land, mostly marshes and bay shores. At +2 m it is 145 km² (56 square miles). Half of the area around Coney Island floods from +1.8 m, Hoboken from +2.3 m, the Meadowlands in New Jersey from +2.5 m and LaGuardia Airport from +2.6 m.
The hatched ground at +2 m covers 89.3 km² (34 square miles): it lies lower than the sea, but in the data a higher strip of ground separates it from the water, such as a road or rail embankment, a levee or a dike.
+3.5 m: about as high as Sandy in 2012
On 29 October 2012 Hurricane Sandy raised the water at The Battery to 4.28 m above mean lower low water (NOAA), about +3.5 m above mean sea level. At that level 431 km² (170 square miles) of the map is under water. Half of the area around Red Hook floods from +3.1 m, JFK Airport from +3.3 m and Lower Manhattan from +3.6 m.
This is not a replay of Sandy: the storm surge lasted a few hours and its height differed from place to place, while the map shows a steady level, the same everywhere. It does show which neighbourhoods lie at a height the water has already reached once.
Why some low ground is hatched
Hatched ground lies below the chosen level, but in the data a higher strip of ground separates it from the sea. The model does not know the culverts, pipes and tide gates under the embankments, so in reality the water may get there sooner. A 10 m grid does not show floodwalls accurately, and some of those built after Sandy may not be in the data yet.
What this experiment shows, and what it does not
Assumptions
- The level on the slider is the mean sea level, the same everywhere. At The Battery the mean higher high water (MHHW) lies 0.76 m higher (NOAA), and storms push the water higher still. The NOAA and Climate Central maps count the rise from MHHW, so at the same "+1 m" they show more water than ours.
- Embankments, levees and dikes keep today's height and do not break. When water spills over one, the ground behind it floods on the map at once.
- The map does not count rain, river floods or the sewers through which the sea can back up into the city.
- This is not a forecast for a given year and not a risk assessment for a particular house or plot. The FEMA and city flood zones describe something else: the risk of flooding in storms.
The data and its accuracy
Land elevation comes from the USGS 3D Elevation Program model at 1/3 arc-second (about 10 m): ground without buildings or trees. The model shows rivers and bays as a flat water surface, and where it holds the bottom instead, we tell it from land because the sea covers it already at +0.1 m. Treat the flooding levels as approximate.
The sea floor comes from the GEBCO grid (cells of about 450 m), so at negative levels the shore is less accurate than on land.